The Absolute Best Pizza in Amarillo [Updated 2024]

Having grown up in Amarillo and having sampled the local pizza scene extensively, I can confidently say that there is no shortage of delicious options in this vibrant Texan city. With a whopping 12 pizza joints reviewed, I can assure you that this guide is based on thorough research and an insatiable love for all things cheesy and delicious.

From classic New York-style slices to innovative gourmet creations, Amarillo offers a diverse range of pizza experiences that are sure to satisfy even the most discerning palates. So, sit back, relax, and let me be your guide to the best pizza in Amarillo!

Big Jim's Pizza Co.

Highlights
Clean
Friendly staff
Good pizza
Fresh ingredients
Varied menu options

Let me start by saying that Big Jim's Pizza Co. is a hidden gem that definitely deserves a spot on the list of the best pizzas in Amarillo. As soon as I walked in, I noticed how clean and inviting the place was, instantly making me feel at ease.

The friendly staff warmly greeted me and guided me through their impressive menu choices and specials. While browsing, I couldn't help but appreciate the delightful aroma of fresh ingredients that filled the air, promising a tantalizing pizza experience.

After much contemplation, I finally settled on their signature pie, topped with a medley of mouthwatering flavors. The first bite of the pizza was a revelation; a perfect blend of a crispy crust with a doughy interior, generously smothered in their savory tomato sauce and loaded with a delicious array of toppings. The flavors danced on my taste buds!

What sets Big Jim's Pizza Co. apart is their commitment to quality and variety. Not only do they make a mean traditional pizza, but they also offer some unique and innovative options to cater to diverse palates. From their tantalizing vegetarian delights to their bold and hearty meat-filled creations, there truly is something for everyone.

Overall, I can confidently say that Big Jim's Pizza Co. is an underrated gem that delivers on every front. From their spotless establishment to their friendly service and extraordinary pies, this place has left a lasting impression on me. So, if you find yourself in Amarillo and craving a sensational pizza experience, make sure to swing by Big Jim's!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Amarillo.

Fire Slice Pizzeria

Highlights
Crispy wings
Delicious pizzas
Quick service
Gluten-free options

Let me start by saying that the delicious pizzas at Fire Slice Pizzeria truly live up to their reputation! From the moment I walked in, the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked dough and melted cheese filled the air, instantly putting a smile on my face.

I decided to start my meal with an order of their crispy wings. Oh boy, was I in for a treat! Each bite was a symphony of flavors, perfectly seasoned and cooked to crispy perfection. The tangy dipping sauce added a delightful kick that complemented the wings beautifully.

Now, onto the main event – the pizzas! Fire Slice Pizzeria offers an impressive variety of toppings and crust options. I opted for their signature pizza topped with classic tomato sauce, gooey mozzarella cheese, and an array of fresh vegetables. The first bite was a revelation! The crust was thin and crispy, providing the perfect base for the rich flavors that danced on my tongue. Each ingredient was carefully selected and perfectly balanced – a true testament to the chef's expertise.

Service at Fire Slice Pizzeria was also commendable, with the staff being attentive and efficient, ensuring that my dining experience was a pleasant one. They even have gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions, ensuring that everyone can enjoy their delectable pizzas.

In conclusion, Fire Slice Pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Amarillo. Their mouthwatering pizzas, crispy wings, quick service, and gluten-free options make it a top contender for the best pizza in town. Don't just take my word for it, go ahead and experience the scrumptiousness for yourself. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Amarillo.

Pizza Planet

Highlights
Love this place
Fast and efficient
Delicious Chef Salad

I have to say, I absolutely love this place! From the moment I walked in, I could tell that Pizza Planet takes their craft seriously. The staff was extremely welcoming and friendly, making me feel right at home.

One thing that really impressed me was how fast and efficient the service was. I didn't have to wait long at all for my order, which is always a plus when you're craving a slice of heaven. The staff worked like a well-oiled machine, delivering piping hot pizzas with a big smile.

But let's talk about the main event: the pizza. Oh boy, was it delicious! I opted for a classic margherita pizza, and it did not disappoint. The thin crust was perfectly crispy, providing the ideal foundation for the rich tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella cheese. Each bite was a symphony of flavors that left me wanting more.

And let me not forget to mention their Chef Salad. It was a delightful surprise amidst all the pizza goodness. Fresh, crisp lettuce topped with a medley of veggies and a tangy dressing, the salad was the perfect accompaniment to my pizza indulgence.

Overall, my visit to Pizza Planet was an absolute delight. With their inviting atmosphere, fast service, and mouth-watering pizzas, this place is definitely one of the top contenders for the title of the best pizza in Amarillo. So, if you're in the area and craving a slice of perfection, don't hesitate to give Pizza Planet a try. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Amarillo.

Pizzeria Nomad

Highlights
Wood-fired pizza
Creative menu items
Tender crust ends
Unique salad
Flavorful wings

Pizzeria Nomad is truly a hidden gem in the pizza scene of Amarillo. As a connoisseur of pizzas, I was immediately drawn to their unique approach of crafting their pizzas in a wood-fired oven. The aroma that filled the air as I entered the restaurant was absolutely tantalizing.

The menu at Pizzeria Nomad is a breath of fresh air, offering a range of creative and adventurous options. While I appreciate the classics, it's always exciting to try something new and different. They certainly didn't disappoint in this aspect.

One standout feature of the pizzas at Pizzeria Nomad is definitely the crust ends. Every bite is a celebration of flavor and texture, with the crust being tender, yet perfectly crisp. It's a little touch that makes a big difference.

But the surprises didn't end with the pizzas. Their unique salad, with its blend of fresh and vibrant ingredients, complemented the pizzas perfectly. It was a refreshing and delicious accompaniment to the main event.

Lastly, I couldn't resist trying their flavorful wings. They were cooked to perfection, with a perfectly balanced combination of spices that had my taste buds dancing with joy.

In conclusion, Pizzeria Nomad stands true to its name by bringing a sense of adventure and exploration to the pizza scene in Amarillo. With their wood-fired pizzas, creative menu items, tender crust ends, unique salad, and flavorful wings, they have truly earned their place as one of the best pizza joints in town. Don't miss out on the opportunity to embark on a culinary journey at Pizzeria Nomad!

You might also want to check out the best steak house in Amarillo.

Mr Gatti's Pizza

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Delicious and fresh food
Fun games for all ages
Discounted game cards for moms
Patient and awesome staff at the prizes counter

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly and welcoming staff. It immediately set the tone for an enjoyable dining experience. As I perused the menu, I couldn't help but notice the variety of options available, from classic pepperoni to unique specialty pizzas. I opted for the Margherita pizza to have a taste of their craftsmanship.

When my pizza arrived at the table, I could already tell it was going to be a winner. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside while remaining delightfully chewy on the inside. Each bite was a burst of flavor, with the fresh ingredients melding together in perfect harmony. The delicious and fresh toppings made all the difference.

What sets Mr Gatti's Pizza apart from other pizzerias is their commitment to creating a fun environment for all. While I enjoyed my meal, I couldn't help but notice the fun games scattered throughout the establishment. It's a great place to bring the family, with activities to keep the kids entertained while waiting for the food to arrive. And speaking of family, I must mention the discounted game cards for moms, which is a thoughtful gesture that adds to the overall experience.

I also had the pleasure of interacting with the patient and awesome staff at the prizes counter. They effortlessly assisted me in redeeming my tickets and made sure that I left with a smile on my face.

Overall, Mr Gatti's Pizza in Amarillo left a lasting impression. With their friendly service, fantastic food, and entertaining atmosphere, it's no wonder they are a top contender for the title of the best pizza in Amarillo.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Amarillo.

Vince's Italian Pizza

Highlights
Amazing
Good service
Delicious
Terrific
Best!

From the moment I stepped into Vince's Italian Pizza, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of freshly baked dough and rich tomato sauce filled the air, igniting my taste buds with anticipation. The staff greeted me with smiles and provided excellent service throughout my visit.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the pizza. Oh boy, it was nothing short of amazing! The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside, yet delightfully fluffy on the inside. Each bite was an explosion of flavors, with a harmonious balance between the tangy tomato sauce and the gooey melted cheese. Vince's Italian Pizza truly knows how to craft a pizza that is an absolute delight for the senses.

But it doesn't stop there. The toppings were delicious, enhancing the flavor profile of every slice. The generous portion of toppings added a delightful texture to each bite. From savory sausage to fresh veggies, each ingredient was carefully selected to create a terrific combination of flavors.

After trying numerous pizza places in Amarillo, I can confidently say that Vince's Italian Pizza is simply the best. The combination of their amazing pizza, good service, and overall deliciousness makes them a top contender for the title of the city's best pizza. Whether you're a local or just passing through Amarillo, do yourself a favor and give Vince's Italian Pizza a try. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best steak in Amarillo.

Pizza Hut

Highlights
Fresh and hot
Quick delivery
Gets order right

Pizza Hut in Amarillo truly lives up to its reputation of serving delicious pizzas. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a warm and inviting aroma of freshly baked dough and savory toppings. The staff were friendly and efficient, making sure to take my order with a smile.

One of the highlights of my visit was the freshness and hotness of the pizzas. Each slice was piping hot with cheese oozing perfectly over the edges. The crust was just the right amount of crispy, giving a satisfying crunch with every bite. It was clear that a lot of care and attention went into crafting these pizzas.

In addition to the incredible taste, the quick delivery time was a pleasant surprise. After placing my order, I barely had time to settle into a booth before my pizza arrived at my table. The efficiency of the staff was commendable and ensured that I didn't have to wait long to indulge in my favorite comfort food.

Not only did they deliver the pizzas promptly, but they also got my order right. Choosing from their extensive menu, I was delighted to see that my customizations were made accurately. It's always a nice feeling when you receive exactly what you asked for, and Pizza Hut did not disappoint in that regard.

In conclusion, Pizza Hut in Amarillo is a top-notch pizza place that satisfies both in taste and service. Their commitment to delivering fresh and hot pizzas, along with their quick delivery and attention to detail, make them stand out among the competition. I highly recommend giving them a try in your quest for the best pizza in Amarillo.

You might also want to check out the best hamburgers in Amarillo.

Palio's Pizza and Bar

Highlights
Fresh and delicious
Excellent service
Legit place to eat
Exceptional food
Best server in a while

Let me start by saying that Palio's Pizza and Bar is a legit place to eat. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The smell of freshly baked pizza filled the air, making my mouth water in anticipation.

I was immediately impressed by the excellent service I received. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, making sure I felt like a valued customer. I couldn't have asked for a better server – she was simply the best server in a while. Her recommendations were spot on, and she made sure my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the pizza. Oh boy, was it a treat for my taste buds! The combination of exquisite ingredients and flawless execution resulted in truly outstanding pizzas. Each bite was a harmonious blend of flavors, leaving me wanting more. The dough was perfectly crisp on the outside, yet soft and chewy on the inside, while the toppings were delicious and generously portioned.

In conclusion, Palio's Pizza and Bar is a must-visit for any pizza lover in Amarillo. The combination of fresh and delicious ingredients, excellent service, and a welcoming atmosphere make it a top contender for the title of the best pizza in town. Don't miss the opportunity to indulge in their exceptional food – your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Amarillo.

Papa Johns Pizza

Highlights
Never fails
Polite staff
Hot and made to order
Generous toppings
Tasty pizzas

Let me start by saying that Papa Johns Pizza in Amarillo is always a go-to choice for me when I'm craving a delicious slice. This place never fails to deliver, both in terms of taste and service.

The polite staff at Papa Johns always greet you with a smile and take your order promptly. They are knowledgeable about their menu and can help you choose the perfect pizza for your taste buds.

One thing I love about this place is that their pizzas are hot and made to order. You can expect your pizza to arrive at your table piping hot, with the cheese perfectly melted and the crust beautifully crispy. The aroma alone is enough to make your mouth water!

When it comes to toppings, Papa Johns is quite generous. Whether you prefer classic toppings like pepperoni and mushrooms or more adventurous options like BBQ chicken and pineapple, they have you covered. The generous toppings ensure every bite is a flavorful explosion.

But it's not just about the toppings - the crust and sauce are equally important. Papa Johns nails both. The crust is just the right balance of chewy and crispy, and the sauce is tangy and full of flavor.

In conclusion, Papa Johns Pizza in Amarillo is a must-visit for any pizza lover. With its never-failing deliciousness, polite staff, hot and made to order pizzas, generous toppings, and tasty flavors, it definitely deserves a spot on the list of the best pizzas in Amarillo.

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Amarillo.

Domino's Pizza

Highlights
Best we've had
Delicious, hot, loaded pizzas
Prompt and good service
Polite and timely delivery

Let me start by saying that Domino's Pizza in Amarillo has impressed me as one of the best pizza places I've visited in this city.

From the moment I walked in, the aroma of fresh dough and melted cheese filled the air, instantly making my mouth water. The harmonious combination of flavors in their pizzas is truly a delight for the taste buds. Each bite is filled with an explosion of taste that keeps you coming back for more.

One thing that stood out to me was the quality of the ingredients. Whether it was the succulent pepperoni or the perfectly melted mozzarella, every topping tasted fresh and flavorful. The pizzas were delicious, hot, and loaded with toppings, leaving me feeling satisfied every time.

The service at Domino's was prompt and of high quality. The staff was polite and attentive to my needs, ensuring that my pizza was made to perfection. Even when experienceing a delivery, the delivery driver was both polite and timely in bringing the piping hot pizza straight to my door.

Overall, Domino's Pizza in Amarillo has left a lasting impression on me. It is my top recommendation for pizza lovers in this city. So, if you're looking for the best we've had in Amarillo, don't miss out on the opportunity to try Domino's Pizza.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Amarillo.

La Bella Pizza Hillside

Highlights
Friendly staff
Delicious food
Fast service

Let me start by saying that the staff at La Bella Pizza Hillside is not only professional, but also incredibly friendly. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warm smiles and a genuine desire to make my experience enjoyable.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the pizza. Oh boy, was it delicious! The flavors were exquisite, with just the right blend of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Each bite was a burst of pure pizza goodness that left me craving more.

One thing that really stood out to me was the fast service. I didn't have to wait long at all for my order to arrive, which is always a plus when you're hungry and eager to dig into a delectable pizza.

In addition to the delectable food and quick service, the ambiance of La Bella Pizza Hillside added a special touch to my dining experience. The cozy atmosphere made me feel right at home, and I could tell that the team takes pride in creating a welcoming environment.

Overall, my visit to La Bella Pizza Hillside was nothing short of spectacular. With friendly staff, delicious food, and fast service, this place definitely sets the bar high for the best pizza in Amarillo. If you find yourself craving a slice of heaven, make sure to give La Bella Pizza Hillside a try.

Little Caesars Pizza

Highlights
Courteous and diligent employees
Freshly made pizza
Awesome customer service
Remarkably low priced
New cheese crust pizzas

Let me start by saying that the employees at Little Caesars Pizza in Amarillo impressed me right from the moment I walked in. They were courteous and diligent, ensuring that all customers were promptly taken care of.

Now, let's talk about the pizza. Little Caesars takes pride in serving freshly made pizza that is sure to delight your taste buds. From the moment I took my first bite, I could tell that the ingredients were of high quality, and the flavors were well-balanced. Whether you prefer classic combinations or more adventurous toppings, they have it all.

What truly sets Little Caesars apart, aside from their incredible flavors, is their awesome customer service. The staff was attentive and always ready to accommodate any special requests. I appreciated their commitment to making sure every customer left with a smile.

And here's the best part- their prices are remarkably low priced! Little Caesars proves that you don't have to break the bank for a delicious pizza. With their affordable prices, you can indulge in their mouthwatering pizzas without guilt.

Lastly, I have to mention their new cheese crust pizzas. These pizzas take indulgence to a whole new level, with a melty, cheesy crust that adds an extra layer of deliciousness to each bite.

In conclusion, my visit to Little Caesars Pizza in Amarillo was a delightful experience. From the freshly made pizza to the awesome customer service, they have truly earned their spot among the best pizza places in Amarillo. So why not head over and taste their incredible pizzas for yourself? You won't be disappointed!