Discover the Best Italian Food in Amarillo (2025)

Each bite of a perfectly made lasagna or a slice of fresh-baked pizza has the power to transport you straight to the heart of Italy. Having scoured the streets of Amarillo, I’ve unearthed seven incredible spots that serve authentic Italian cuisine, each with its own unique flair.

With years of experience tasting dishes from tiny trattorias to bustling pizzerias, I’ve developed a discerning palate that lets me separate the wheat from the chaff. Trust me when I say that these locations not only deliver on flavor but also bring a slice of Italian culture right to our Texas town. Prepare your taste buds for an unforgettable culinary journey!

Mac Joe's

The authentic flavors range from exquisite pasta dishes, to a wide range of Italian specialties. With their friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere, Mac Joe's is truly a one-of-a-kind restaurant.

I have to say that I was most impressed with the lasagna. It was cooked perfectly and the ricotta cheese added a creamy layer that was simply delightful. My dining partner enjoyed the spinach ravioli which had a delicious tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.

To top off our meal, we decided to indulge in a tiramisu for dessert. The creaminess and sweetness of this classic Italian dessert totally hit the spot!

Overall, Mac Joe's offers some of the best italian food in Amarillo. Their menu offers interesting takes on classic Italian favorites, making it well worth the visit - whether you're an Amarillo native or just passing through town!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Amarillo.

Toscana Italian Steakhouse

The menu is full of classic Italian dishes, as well as some unique twists to the traditional fare. I had a ravioli dish that was truly one of the best ravioli dishes I've ever had! The flavor was fresh and vibrant, complemented by a delicious tomato sauce.

The steak options were excellent too! The filet mignon was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of char. Not to mention the truffle mashed potatoes – a must try if you're in the mood for something special!

What really sets this place apart from other italian restaurants is their focus on creating memorable experiences – everything from the decor to their attentive wait staff. I would highly recommend Toscana Italian Steakhouse for anyone looking for the best Italian food in Amarillo.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Amarillo.

Pizzeria Nomad

The atmosphere here is that of a typical Italian pizzeria with a rustic, warm ambiance. The wait staff is friendly and attentive, making sure to stay on top of any requests as soon as possible.

The food itself is simply unbeatable. Their pizza dough is made in-house using the freshest ingredients around, giving it an unmistakable flavor and texture. From their classic marinara to their white veggie pizza, each bite of Pizzeria Nomad's pizza is truly delightful!

The service here is also top-notch; the waiters are incredibly knowledgeable about their menu and always take the time to explain each item thoroughly. I also appreciate that they make sure everyone feels welcome and taken care of, no matter what.

Overall, Pizzeria Nomad has certainly earned its title as being the best Italian food in Amarillo. It's definitely worth a visit if you're in town!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Amarillo.

Fire Slice Pizzeria

I've been a big fan of Fire Slice Pizzeria since I was a kid growing up in Amarillo, and I have to say that their pizzas are still some of the best around! The crust is perfectly crisp and flavorful, the sauce is always delicious, and topping options range from classic to creative.

The other Italian dishes on the menu are also delicious. From homemade pastas to tasty calzones, there's something for everyone. And don't forget their garlic bread - it's the best!

The atmosphere at Fire Slice Pizzeria is also worth mentioning. It has all the charm of an old-school pizza parlor but with all the modern amenities you'd expect. The staff is friendly and attentive, which helps add to a great dining experience.

Overall, Fire Slice Pizzeria is definitely one of my favorite places in Amarillo for Italian food. If you're looking for the best Italian food in Amarillo, you can't go wrong at Fire Slice!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Amarillo.

Rotini and the Alfredo's

As soon as I walked in, the smell of freshly cooked pasta and herbs filled the air. The restaurant was clean and the staff were super friendly.

I decided to try their Chicken Alfredo, which is their specialty! The dish had just the right amount of cheese and spice that was incredibly delicious. The chicken was cooked to perfection - tender and juicy!

The highlight, however, was their homemade rotini noodles which were perfectly cooked- al dente, as they should be! They went so well with the rich cream sauce that accompanied it.

Overall, Rotini and Alfredo's is one of my favorite Italian restaurants in Amarillo because of the quality of their food and service. The ambience is great making it a perfect spot for an intimate dinner or a coffee get-together with friends. I highly recommend this place if you're looking for some great Italian food in Amarillo!

You might also want to check out the best steak house in Amarillo.

Abuelo's Mexican Restaurant

With a vast and tantalizing menu of traditional Mexican specialties, Abuelo's offers the best italian food in Amarillo. The delicious homemade tamales are amazing, with a perfect mix of spices that never fails to please. The nachos come with so much flavor that it’s impossible to stop eating them. The tacos are also especially noteworthy, as they offer an interesting twist on the classic recipes that you won't find anywhere else.

The atmosphere at Abuelo's is also top-notch - the staff is always friendly and attentive and the decor is inviting and cozy. It truly captures the spirit of Mexico and makes you feel right at home.

Whether you're looking for a quick bite or an evening out with friends, Abuelo's is definitely worth a try! I cannot recommend it enough for its flavorful italian food and warm atmosphere.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Amarillo.

Pizza Planet

My recent visit to Pizza Planet in Amarillo was a delightful culinary adventure! The aroma of freshly baked pizza greeted me upon arrival, and the playful atmosphere set the tone for a fun dining experience. I couldn't resist their signature "Galactic Supreme" pizza, topped with zesty pepperoni, vibrant veggies, and a rich, cheesy blend that danced on my palate. The crust was perfectly crispy, delivering that satisfying bite. Don’t miss their house-made marinara—it’s a game changer! If you’re looking for a slice of joy in Amarillo, Pizza Planet is a must-try for every pizza lover! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best steak in Amarillo.