The Absolute Best Mexican Bakery in Amarillo [Updated 2024]

I've been eating these mexican treats for years, so I'm not just randomly picking a place out of thin air. To make sure I get the best experience, I've tried a total of six bakeries here in Amarillo.

I know what I'm looking for and how it should be done—authentic ingredients, fresh bakes, attentive service and a welcoming atmosphere. Every detail goes into my ratings to ensure you get an accurate review.

Throughout this journey, I found that each bakery had something unique to offer but there's one that stands out from rest. Come with me as I take you through the journey of finding the Best Mexican Bakery in Amarillo!

Girasol Cafe and Bakery

The atmosphere is always inviting and the staff is incredibly friendly. The bakery offers a wide variety of fresh-baked items every day. The pastries are especially amazing, as they have a unique blend of sweet mexican flavors that appeal to any palate!

The service at Girasol Cafe and Bakery can't be beat; it's quick, efficient, and always with a smile. Not only do they provide excellent customer service, but they also make sure that their products are of high quality. Every item I've bought has been absolutely delicious!

The prices at Girasol Cafe and Bakery are very reasonable and the portions are generous. It's easy to get more than enough to satisfy your sweet tooth craving! Even better, you can pick up individual treats to go for a little snack throughout the day.

In conclusion, Girasol Cafe and Bakery is without a doubt the best mexican bakery in Amarillo. The staff is friendly, prices are reasonable, and their pastries are simply divine!

You might also want to check out the best mexican breakfast in Amarillo.

Sweet by Cara Linn

I was blown away by the quality and variety of Mexican desserts available at Sweet. The churros were some of the best I've ever tasted; they were freshly-fried and perfectly crispy on the outside yet soft and fluffy on the inside, and they came with a generous serving of creamy chocolate dip. The tres leches cake was light and moist, with just the right amount of sweetness.

The atmosphere at Sweet by Cara Linn was also wonderful; the staff was welcoming, friendly, and knowledgeable about their products. The decorations were bright and festive, adding to the overall enjoyment of visiting Sweet.

I would highly recommend Sweet by Cara Linn to anyone looking for a truly delightful mexican bakery experience! It's truly the best mexican bakery in Amarillo.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Amarillo.

Nothing Bundt Cakes

The cakes are made with the freshest ingredients, fresh fruits and spices for a truly authentic taste of Mexico. The cake decorators have a flair for the traditional yet modern at the same time, creating beautiful creations that will please everyone from the most traditional to the more adventurous.

The flavors are incredible! From sweet Mexican Chocolate Cakes to their signature Lemon Raspberry Bundt Cake, they offer something for every taste. I was especially impressed by their Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese frosting - it was bold and delicious!

On top of all that, the prices were surprisingly affordable. Portions are generous and you really get what you pay for. And since they ship nationwide, I'm always able to get my favorite cakes delivered right to my door no matter where I am.

Overall, Nothing Bundt Cakes is the best mexican bakery in Amarillo and I'd highly recommend them if you want an amazing cake without having to break the bank!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Amarillo.

Benjamin's Donut Bakery

Their pastries and treats are unbeatable. Each one is handmade with nothing but the finest ingredients, and you can taste the quality in every bite. The owner, Benjamin, is a true master of his craft, and it shows in the delicious flavor of his creations.

The customer service at Benjamin's Donut Bakery is also top-notch. They always greet me with a warm smile and make sure to provide me with helpful advice on which pastry or treat would best suit my needs. The atmosphere inside the bakery is incredibly welcoming too; I often find myself lingering longer than I had planned just because it feels so inviting!

All-in-all, I would highly recommend Benjamin's Donut Bakery to anyone looking for the best mexican bakery in Amarillo. Its treats are simply exquisite, its customer service exemplary, and its atmosphere unbeatable - what more could you ask for?

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Amarillo.

Blue Crane Bakery

I was amazed by their wide variety of goods. From traditional conchas and tres leches cakes to a creative selection of cookies, every pastry I tried was delicious!

The atmosphere at Blue Crane is also top-notch. It has the perfect balance between a modern and rustic feel, and their staff is always friendly and helpful.

What really impressed me was that all of their ingredients are organic and locally sourced. This means that not only do they make quality pastries, but they are environmentally conscious as well!

Overall, I would highly recommend Blue Crane Bakery to anyone looking for the best mexican bakery in Amarillo.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Amarillo.

El Paleton

Their selection of delicious baked goods is extensive and I'm always amazed at the variety. They have something for everyone, from a classic Mexican pan dulce to the sweet treats like churros and pound cake!

The quality is top-notch and the freshness is unbeatable, you can tell they put great care into every item they make. Not to mention their prices are incredibly reasonable, making El Paleton one of the most affordable options in town.

I would say that El Paleton may just be the best mexican bakery in Amarillo. If you're ever looking for some amazing baked treats that your taste buds won't forget, this is definitely a great option!

You might also want to check out the best steak house in Amarillo.