The Absolute Best Sandwich in Amarillo [Updated 2024]

I have plenty of experience when it comes to testing out sandwiches, and after careful review of a variety of sandwich establishments around town, I've narrowed it down to the best 6 sandwiches Amarillo has to offer.

In this article you'll find my picks for the top sandwich in Amarillo, all presented with descriptions complete with my lighthearted opinion on why each one stands out.

I'm confident that by the end of our culinary journey together through Amarillo's best sandwiches, you'll be licking your lips and ready to take a bite!

Schlotzsky's

I've had my fair share of sandwiches from all around the world, so I'm confident in saying that Schlotzsky's sandwiches are among the best. The fresh-baked breads and unique flavors are just a few of the reasons why. From their classic Original sandwich to their adventurous flavors like Chicken Bacon Cheddar, each sandwich is filled with flavor and fresh ingredients. Not to mention the generous portion sizes, which leave you fully satisfied after every meal!

In conclusion, I can confidently say Schlotzsky's offers the best sandwich in Amarillo. With unique flavors, generous portions and quality ingredients, they have something for everyone. If you're looking for a great sandwich in Amarillo, look no further than Schlotzsky's!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Amarillo.

Pan-Handlers Café

The restaurant has a wide variety of sandwiches from classic BLTs to paninis - there's something for everyone. I tried the Prime Rib Sandwich and was amazed at its flavor; the prime rib was cooked to perfection, with a slight crisp on the outside, and juicy tenderness on the inside. The bread was fresh and soft, complimenting the ingredients perfectly.

Overall I found Pan-Handlers Café to have one of the best sandwiches in Amarillo! The restaurant is clean and welcoming, great for lunch or dinner. I'd highly recommend it to anyone looking for a great sandwich in Amarillo!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Amarillo.

FAVs

The first time I tried FAVs, I knew it was something special. The ingredients are fresh and the bread is perfectly soft. From their Italian sandwich to their amazing Philly cheesesteak I could tell that a lot of effort has been put into perfecting these recipes.

I also have to mention their sides; they are just as delicious as the sandwiches! Their homemade coleslaw and potato salad have the perfect amount of tanginess that complements every bite. The french fries are always cooked just right and you can tell they are made with quality ingredients.

Overall, I believe that FAVs has some of the best sandwiches in Amarillo and I would definitely recommend them. There's something for everyone here, whether you're looking for a light snack or a full meal, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Amarillo.

McAlister's Deli

I was first attracted to McAlister's Deli because of their extensive selection of sandwiches. From classic favorites like the turkey and Swiss to their more specialized regional sandwiches, like their Tex-Mex Grille and New Orleans Po' Boy, they have something for everyone.

The quality of the ingredients is one of the reasons why I keep coming back to McAlister's Deli; they use only the best so that every bite you take is packed with flavor. Every sandwich uses fresh meats and cheeses as well as flavorful condiments that bring each sandwich to life.

Another great thing about McAlister's Deli is that they are very accommodating to dietary restrictions; not only do they offer vegetarian options but also gluten-free breads! So everyone can still enjoy a delicious sandwich no matter what dietary restrictions they may have.

If you're looking for the best sandwich in Amarillo then look no further than McAlister's Deli. You will be amazed by their selection, flavor combinations, and willingness to accommodate those with dietary restrictions all while enjoying a scrumptious sandwich!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Amarillo.

Bagel Place

I have tried a wide variety of sandwiches but the best sandwich I have had is the Bagel Place’s “Tuna BLT”. It's the perfect combination of tuna, lettuce, tomatoes and bacon with a creamy mayo sauce. The blend of flavors and textures truly captured my taste buds and left me wanting more!

The atmosphere was also amazing. All employees were incredibly friendly and helpful when I asked them questions about their selections. From the moment I walked in, I felt very welcome.

What really set Bagel Place apart for me was the variety of options. Whether it be salads, flatbreads, breakfast sandwiches or traditional bagels, they have something for everyone. Additionally, the prices are affordable: you won't find yourself breaking the bank here!

I cannot recommend Bagel Place enough! They offer an excellent selection of fresh food that is made with care and served to you in a warm environment. Look no further if you're searching for the best sandwich in Amarillo!

You might also want to check out the best steak house in Amarillo.

The Eatery on Route 66

I love the atmosphere of this establishment – it's cozy and inviting. The staff is always friendly and the wait times are minimal.

But, most importantly, the food is amazing! The sandwich I had was freshly made with high-quality ingredients and cooked perfectly! The ratio of bread to meat was spot on and I really enjoyed the condiments that were selected to complement the sandwich.

In my opinion, The Eatery on Route 66 has the best sandwich in Amarillo! It has a great price point too – making it a great spot for lunch or dinner any day of the week.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Amarillo.